It was hegemonic in the sense defined by kindleberger 1973, 1974it underwrote the system of fixed exchange rates, and operated. Economic power imbalances are embedded in the operation of global markets and in the ownership and governance of international institutions. Global governance will be interpreted as a possibly hegemonic discourse of postfordist international politics. Oct 27, 2015 this edited collection makes a highly significant critical contribution to the field of environmental politics.
When structural arguments enter the analysis, they usually do so with regard to the. This article develops a model for analysing environmental regime formation which emphasizes how the interplay between states and markets produces particular conditions for institutional change. This article considers the parameters of resistance to global environmental governance and argues that the idea of ecoimperialism reflects the uncertain location of politics, the ambivalent role of states, and challenges assumptions in the mainstream study of. For example, consider levys study of corporate responses to the climate change issue. From interstate regimes to counter hegemonic struggles matthew paterson, david humphreys. International environmental regimesespecially those regimes articulated in multilateral environmental agreementshave been a subject of intense interest within the scientific community over the last three decades.
An important and timely exploration of a topic at the forefront of global debate, environmental governance is essential reading for all students of global environmental politics, international political economy and international relations. American hegemony and the global environment robert falkner. Invoking gramscian concepts, okereke 2008 sought to demonstrate the importance and use of discursive power in global. These studies have discussed, for example, the counterhegemonic power of ngos in transformative practice girei, 2016. Environmental governance power and knowledge in a local. May 02, 2003 governance has become one of the key themes in global environmental politics gep. Hegemonic power refers to power, status, or influence towards others in an indirect manner. A neogramscian perspective on varieties of environmental governance.
Mar 30, 20 among the attractions of such an approach are that 1 cases of failure to create international regimes as well as cases of success are important to understand the emergence of global governance institutions, and 2 the different roles of various state actors should be understood beyond hegemonic power. He argued that these hegemonic or fieldshaping norms are generally legitimized through organizational and discursive practices see also liberal environmentalism. Hegemonic stability theory is a theory that attempts to explain changes in the degree to which the international political economy is open or restricted on the basis of the power relations between the major states in the world system. Apr 12, 2011 the global environmental agenda may be viewed by developing states and societies as a neoimperialist adventure to be resisted. However, whereas gilpin views hegemony from the structural realist perspective in thinking about systemic change i. The change in thinking about environmental governance is most clearly visible in the new attention. Through a quantitative analysis looking at both american and british hegemonic governance, it was discovered that in both cases there is a strong negative. The issue of power is addressed in power in global governance barnett and duvall 2005. Article information, pdf download for towards a critical politics of. This acclaimed book by gabriela kutting is available at in several formats for. Good environmental governance takes into account the role. Power here is explored in all its guises from relational to structural power. Post hegemonic global governance japanese journal of. Apr 18, 2019 this article analyses chinas strategic intentions and how these may ultimately project its violent or peaceful hegemonic rise.
Although the current era, routinely dubbed the information age, has witnessed the growing centrality of informational processes in economic, political, social and cultural institutions and developments, not much attention has focussed on the role of information in environmental protection and governance. Private environmental governance and international relationsrobert falkner private environmentalgovernance and international relations. Introduction this article develops a critical political economy account of global environmental governance to improve upon our understanding of the contemporary conduct of. American hegemony and the global environment international. Cooperation by the non hegemonic actor, or its compliance to certain states of affairs, does not necessarily mean consensus. Among the attractions of such an approach are that 1 cases of failure to create international regimes as well as cases of success are important to understand the emergence of global governance institutions, and 2 the different roles of various state actors should be understood beyond hegemonic power. Pdf regimes in global environmental governance and the. Business strategyand international environmentalgovernance. A possible model for arctic governance, the authors assert that as the environmental, economic, and security impacts of the arctic are global in nature, its governance should also be correspondingly global, and the united states, as both an arctic state and the largest economy in the world, should take the lead in fostering international. This paper raises critical questions about the relationship between knowledge translation and hegemonic power, and the way that this relationship shapes particular forms of neoliberal climate governance. Environmental governanceenvironmental management some reflections by james murombedzi 19th july 20 there is a deep structural link between the use and control of resources and the organization and exercise of power. Groundwater governance a global framework for action. Keywords civil society, environmental governance, hegemony.
A possible model for arctic governance, the authors assert that as the environmental, economic, and security impacts of the arctic are global in nature, its governance should also be correspondingly global, and the united states, as both an arctic state and the largest economy in the world, should take the lead in fostering international cooperation in the arctic. Power imbalances in northsouth relations reside in the military and economic spheres and in that of knowledge. Governance includes government, business and civil society, and emphasizes whole system management. As the worlds largest supplier, chinas rare earth industry has developed. This paper examines hegemonic stability theory, the concept in international relations that an assertive hegemon can act as a stabilizing force in the international system. Counterterrorism and international power relations.
For example, the relationship between governance, power and leaders role as suggested by sotarauta 2016 that arise by considering placebased leadership as a complex metaconcept constituted by. This paper compares asean environmental governance and transnational private governance. It maintains that, although it is difficult to define accurately chinas future hegemonic role and general systemic behaviour, a third hegemonic way or dutch. Effectiveness of international environmental regimes. Groundwater policy and governance thematic paper 5. The political economy of global environmental governance. Soft power and global governance with chinese characteristics. Counterhegemonic narratives and the politics of plurality. However, there are substantial differences of opinion regarding the effectiveness of these governance systems or the degree to which they. If a certain group has a certain influence over the other.
If applied in a society or group of people for example, hegemonic power is typically assumed by a dominant group from within. It is tempting to assume that global environmental governance represents a compelling example of the hegemonic power of the north over the south. Organizing the environmental governance portsmouth research. Water scarcity and transnational environmental governance. However, this research focused on the disruptions in the global system that seemed to challenge the idea that global environmental governance is a carefully and fully implemented regime of power. A chineseinspired reconstruction roda mushkat abstract the challenge of protecting the biosphere has both salient academic and policy dimensions. Cubas development model is embedded in its socialist project, which has been historically contested by hegemonic paradigms. Global environmental governance geg is the sum of organizations, policy instruments, financing mechanisms, rules, procedures and norms that regulate the processes of global environmental protection. May 28, 2010 the field of international relations is replete with contentious debates over both theory and policy, but hegemonic stability theory has elicited controversy from theoreticians and policymakers alike. Environmental governance comprises the rules, practices, policies and institutions that shape how humans interact with the environment. This study aims to discuss the changing hegemonic struggles among the state, business and ngos in the development of environmental governance of chinas rare earth industry. In line with a critical theoretical perspective, which sees global environmental governance as embedded in the wider neoliberal global political economy, this article argues that accounts of global environmental governance grounded in orthodox international relations lack an analysis of agency and power relations. Rather than reading off the potential power and authority of.
Climate change and the transition to neoliberal environmental governance. Hegemonic struggles in chinas rare earth industry le bo a thesis submitted for the degree of doctor of philosophy essex business school university of essex february, 2016. Governance and nominating committee charter purpose of the governance and nominating committee the governance and nominating committee the governance committee is. Central questions to the debate are whether a hegemonic actor is well placed to shape the system, what strategies hegemonic powers use to define the system, if there are particular costs and benefits associated with exercising hegemonic influence, if other states gain or lose from hegemony, and under what conditions hegemonic powers endure.
It is widely acknowledged that private actors play an increasing role in. Conceptualizing environmental governance on the gbm basin. Global environmental politics do not give rise to a hegemonic power in the tra ditional sense of a. This acclaimed book by gabriela kutting is available at in several formats for your ereader. Aug 21, 2012 power here is explored in all its guises from relational to structural power. And nearly always, visible waterthat is, surface waterwas the main subject of inquiry. Climate governance in an international system under. Newell the centrality of business in negotiating, structuring, and implementing regimes of international environmental governance is all too obvious to negotiation participants. Environmental governance united nations environment. This edited volume, however, largely neglects the factors which are going to.
To complete the story, however, the nile basin initiative demonstrates that the hydro hegemonic power zeitoun and warner 2006 of egypt is not total, and cooperative frameworks for watersharing continue to develop. Control over resources is the ultimate source ofm power shivji 1998. American hegemony and the global environment jstor. Post hegemonic global governance volume 16 issue 3 peter m. Organizing the environmental governance of the rareearth. Exploring the links robert falkner this article is concerned with private environmental governance at the global level. Governance has become one of the key themes in global environmental politics gep. The environment and international relations the question of when, if, and how well national governments cooperate to address shared environmental problems, from climate change to biodiversity loss to international trade in hazardous wastes, to name but a few, is central to the relationship between international relations theory.
The united states and rising powers in a post hegemonic global order sevastieleni vezirgiannidou. Introducrion the first quarter of the 21 st century, as the scope of foreign interventions and international power. American hegemony and the global environment citeseerx. Effective environmental governance at all levels is critical for finding solutions to these challenges. Global civil society and global environmental governance. While the emergence of increased chinese and indian political, economic, and military power has changed the chemistry of events and forces shaping globalization, western governmental, commercial, military, and religious interests are still controlling. On the academic side, persistent efforts have been made in the field of sociolegal studies to enhance the understanding of the. How soft power shapes transboundary water interaction. The united states and rising powers in a post hegemonic global order, international affairs, volume 89, issue 3. The ability of environmental governance to handle power rests, in part, in how well governance structures, institutions, and processes fulfill the objective of equity, which can facilitate recognition of diverse groups and worldviews, inclusion of stakeholders in decision.
A neogramscian perspective on varieties of environmental. Power and knowledge in a localglobal world by gabriela kutting editor pdf free download ebook. International system of conservative hegemony and paralysis of. Students will receive a grade based on the following activities 1.
Hegemonic stability theory posits that an assertive hegemon can act as a stabilizing force in the international system. Richard levins 85th birthday popular power and environmental governance. The efficacy of global environmental governance will ultimately depend on implementation at global and domestic levels. They start from the premise that climate change is a central civilizing force of our times. To some extent, a link can be established between us predominance in the international political economy and the rise of global. Environmental governance deficit is a reflection of governance barriers at the. Project muse challenging global environmental governance. In accounting for the rise of international environmental regimes and governance, the majority of environmental scholars have used neoliberal institutionalist, cognitivist, or transnationalist arguments haas 1990. So, too, does the interest of certain oil exporting states in the gulf in carbon capture and storage ccs and. Climate change and the transition to neoliberal environmental.
Problematising global environmental governance from latin america through the case of bolivia michela coletta and malayna raftopoulos this article seeks to problematise current frameworks of global environmental governance by examining. Jun 30, 2016 the paper argues that realization of shortage of water and environmental degradation as an interdependent problem, influence of an inclusive epistemic community cognitive condition and a hegemonic leadership power is willing to accept the relative gain of others states for the absolute gain of itselfare required to foster water resource. Global governance as the hegemonic project of transatlantic civil society. Nov 04, 2005 without documentation of the extent of hegemonic power in shaping existing environmental practices it is hard to know whether a ruling coalition is really being displaced or reformed at all. In addition, the research analyses the connection of these factors with the practice of environmental governance within the cuban development model. Although rare earths are indispensable to myriad clean technologies, mining and processing rare earth ores cause heavy pollution. Global environmental politics do not give rise to a hegemonic power in the tra ditional sense of. Falkner, robert private environmental governance and. International environmental governance and the paris. Military power imbalances are significant but are outside the scope of the paper. Whilst political ecology has rightly explored and exposed the heterogeneity of communities in communitybased environmental governance, pointing to the diverse interests and dynamic power relations inherent within them, it has not extended this same attention to the importance of intersectional identities and multiple knowledges of the. This paper concludes that a hegemonic power is very important for international political economy stability.
Environmental governance is a concept in political ecology and environmental policy that advocates sustainability sustainable development as the supreme consideration for managing all human activitiespolitical, social and economic. Jun 23, 2014 if soft power is like a beauty contest, and if global governance can be nothing other than what the united states has practiced, china has indeed failed miserably in both soft power and global governance. To do this, we have to begin by explicating the evolution of hegemony and power relations within the historical context beginning from theoretical origins. Shifts in the world political economy the decline of us hegemony, the shift of power towards china and the east, and the emergence of a new multipolarity.
Hegemony international relations oxford bibliographies. Successful framing by the stronger party as the common good soft power, however, can result in power differences going uncontested and countries signing treaties that bring highly differential benefits. It is about questions concerning how we make environmental decisions and who makes them. Without a strong hegemonic power the stability in economics and politics is impossible. In a further step i sketch out the transformations of international politics and its contradictions in order to show how the discourse and structural transformations articulate with each other. Counter hegemonic narratives and the politics of plurality. United states and rising powers in a posthegemonic global. It argues that the internationallevel, institutionalist approach to global environmental politics has run its course, employed solely by powerful actors in order to orchestrate and manipulate local communities within a continuing hegemonic system. Therefore, cubas socialist model is examined in relation to the.
67 809 401 30 1196 129 119 1325 601 474 1559 33 1032 1285 44 355 698 186 691 1247 1239 518 872 998 847 1099 601 1042 1216 1226 388 1002 346 184 66 1233 1048